The Pakistani drama series “Tere Bin” has sparked controversy with its portrayal of a marital rape scene. The show’s writer, Nooran Makhdoom, has defended the inclusion of the scene, stating that it is a necessary element in the storyline. This article delves into the ongoing debate surrounding the controversial episode, exploring Makhdoom’s response to the criticism and the wider context of such portrayals onscreen.
The Controversial Scene in “Tere Bin”
In episode 46 of “Tere Bin,” viewers witness a scene where Murtasim, played by Wahaj Ali, seemingly forces himself on his wife, Meerab, portrayed by Yumna Zaidi. The intense nature of the scene has ignited strong reactions among the audience, leading to a significant backlash against the show and its writer.
Fans React to the Downfall of Murtasim’s Character Arc
The sudden change in Murtasim’s character arc has been met with disappointment from fans. Many argue that the shift feels unnecessary and undermines the development of the character up to that point. The promo for the next episode suggests that the theme of marital rape will be further explored, causing shockwaves among the fanbase.
Nooran Makhdoom’s Defense
Nooran Makhdoom, the writer of “Tere Bin,” has addressed the criticism surrounding the controversial scene. In an interview with Arab News, she explains that the scene was a necessary demand of the serial that would ultimately lead to the climax of the story. Makhdoom emphasizes that audiences should withhold judgment until they have seen the entire story unfold, rather than taking issue with each individual episode.
Absence of Objections from the Content Team and Production House
As Nooran Makhdoom explains, neither the content team nor the production house expressed objections to the idea of creating a new story and scene throughout the drama. This suggests that the creative decisions were made collectively, with the consent and support of the show’s stakeholders. Makhdoom adds that similar themes have been depicted onscreen before, but the strong reaction stems from the wide recognition and popularity of the “Tere Bin” project.
Marital Rape Onscreen: A Repeated Occurrence
Makhdoom asserts that the inclusion of marital rape in “Tere Bin” is not an unprecedented event. She points to a previous Pakistani drama, “Ranjha Ranjha Kardi,” featuring Imran Ashraf and Iqra Aziz, which also faced criticism for its portrayal of marital rape. This suggests that the topic has been explored in Pakistani television dramas before, indicating an ongoing debate within the industry.
Creative Freedom and Social Responsibility
Regarding the infamous spitting and slapping scene in the previous episode, Makhdoom clarifies that it was not part of the original script but was incorporated during the shooting. However, she stands by the scene and the script, defending her creative choices. Makhdoom believes that as a writer, she has the freedom to create stories as she sees fit, and she remains steadfast in her decision to include such scenes. While acknowledging her social responsibility, Makhdoom emphasizes that the portrayal of controversial themes is not an unusual occurrence in television dramas.
Backlash and Divergent Opinions
The upcoming episode of “Tere Bin Pakistani Drama” has generated significant backlash on social media platforms. Many users express anger and reservations about the content, highlighting concerns about the potential normalization of marital rape. However, there are also those who see the criticism as an opportunity to address problematic portrayals in television dramas, welcoming the audience’s growing awareness and willingness to challenge such content.
THE ABSOLUTE TRUTH! Very well articulated! This is why we felt or fell for Murtasim er even Meerasim for that fact! The reason why it’s the most anticipated drama in the recent times! Since the liking was at peak, the trauma hit hard! No credits to Nooran whatsoever! #TereBin pic.twitter.com/4X7D16nyxE
— Rimmi🌦 (@BedaTarrJaye) May 22, 2023
Very much unlike other crimes where the accused is innocent until proven guilty,an alleged rapist is guilty unless proven so or otherwise.
I am shaken seeing some girls still supporting MK.Girls!!Wtf?Ok wait for Wed but dont try to justify him!
— Meerab Waqas Ahmed✨(DDQ) 🔥 (@Dusk041) May 21, 2023
— Aranya Kapoor♥️ (@aranyakapoor) May 21, 2023
— Yumhaj❤_Zone (@MalihaKhan36869) May 23, 2023
Contextualizing the Controversy
The inclusion of sensitive and controversial topics in television dramas is not unique to “Tere Bin” or Pakistani television. Around the world, various forms of media, including television shows and films, have tackled challenging subjects to provoke thought and generate discussions. These portrayals aim to shed light on important social issues, even if they may be uncomfortable or disturbing to watch.
Impact and Responsibility of Media
Media, including television dramas, holds a significant influence over society. It has the power to shape perceptions, challenge societal norms, and initiate conversations. Therefore, creators, writers, and producers bear a responsibility to handle sensitive subjects with care and thoughtfulness. While it is essential to portray reality, it is equally important to be aware of the potential impact and repercussions of such portrayals.
Addressing the Concerns
The negative response to the “Tere Bin” episode involving marital rape reflects a growing awareness and sensitivity toward the portrayal of violence against women in media. Critics argue that depicting such scenes without proper context and sensitivity could trivialize or normalize a grave issue like marital rape. It highlights the need for content creators to exercise caution and consider the potential consequences of their creative choices.
Balancing Artistic Freedom and Ethical Considerations
The debate surrounding the inclusion of controversial scenes in television dramas often revolves around the delicate balance between artistic freedom and ethical considerations. While creative freedom allows writers and filmmakers to explore complex narratives, it is crucial to approach sensitive subjects responsibly. This entails providing proper context, raising awareness, and promoting discussions that contribute to a more informed and empathetic society.
The Role of Audience Engagement
The strong reaction to the marital rape scene in “Tere Bin” demonstrates the power of audience engagement. Social media has provided a platform for viewers to express their opinions, concerns, and frustrations. This feedback plays a vital role in holding content creators accountable and influencing future portrayals of sensitive topics.
The Way Forward
The controversy surrounding “Tere Bin” serves as a catalyst for discussions on responsible storytelling and ethical considerations in the media industry. It highlights the importance of collaboration between content creators, production houses, and audiences to ensure that sensitive topics are handled thoughtfully and with proper context. This dialogue can pave the way for more nuanced and responsible portrayals of complex issues in television dramas.
- The Family Business Season 5
- Arthdal Chronicles Season 2 Release Date 2023
- All of Us Are Dead Season 2 Release Date Countdown
The inclusion of a marital rape scene in the Pakistani drama series “Tere Bin” has sparked intense debate and backlash. The writer, Nooran Makhdoom, defends the scene, emphasizing its importance in the storyline and urging viewers to reserve judgment until the entire story unfolds. The controversy surrounding this episode reflects the broader discussions on the portrayal of sensitive topics in television dramas, artistic freedom, and ethical responsibilities. It highlights the need for content creators, production houses, and audiences to engage in a meaningful dialogue to ensure responsible storytelling and the promotion of empathy and awareness in society.